Creating Waves of Awareness
Single Remedy vs Combinations
Tags: Single, combination, community, homeopathy, remedy, world
Replies to This Discussion
-
Permalink Reply by Dr. Gary Weaver on -
now that reads perfectly in Flemish, English and Urdu!!
thank you..
lol
-
Permalink Reply by sajjadakram on -
You want to say that simillarity is most important than the strength of the medicine.
sajjad.
-
Permalink Reply by Vaikunthanath das Kaviraj. on -
Yes, that is what I want to say. We prescribe on symptom similarity and not on the strength of the medicine.
What "strength" do you want to ascribe to a medicine other than the fact that in repeated doses it is capable of setting up symptoms in the healthy? And that also not in everyone.
If it was about strength, the remedies would work unconditionally, whereas we know that although Hahnemann asserts this for tinctures - with which he made provings in the beginning - it is not so for potencies, which he also admits in the Organon.
We all know that when a remedy does not "fit" the constitution of a prover, that no symptoms will be produced. I have done provings of remedies and not all caused a proving in me. That is personal experience and proven by experiment.
So he cannot have it both ways. It is either on symptoms similarity or on strength and it cannot ever be both.
That said, in someone who does fit the constitutional idiosyncrasy, the potency must also match the vitality or sensitivity of the patient. Otherwise you create a strong aggravation, but even that concept is based on similarity.
-
Permalink Reply by sajjadakram on
-
the potency must also match the vitality or sensitivity of the patient. Otherwise you create a strong aggravation, but even that concept is based on similarity.
Thanks.It is truth.
sajjad.
-
Permalink Reply by Rajesh Bhide on -
'' success '' means what for you ?? that the pathology gets better ? if this is what you think then you are not even a homeopath.
there is only one key to one lock. it is absolutely against the homeopathic principles to use combinations and patent remedies. Lazy homeopaths who dont want to work hard and earn quick money and popularity do that. u better practise allopathy than this kind of homeopathy.
-
Permalink Reply by Vaikunthanath das Kaviraj. on
-
Exactly.
-
Permalink Reply by Dr Muhammed Rafeeque on -
As far as a beginner is concerned, there is nothing wrong in asking whether single remedy is good or combinations. They have the right to know such basic things. Because Homoeopathy is not a religion, it is a science. So without knowing the real fact, how can they try to become a better prescriber tomorrow? And it is our duty to make them understand the best way. The experienced practitioners can tell that the single remedy is the right choice. So, with due respect, let me tell you that we have to be more gentle in giving answers, especially to the neonates who may get emotionally hurt easily. Instead of pushing them to allopathy, we should bring them to the scientific homoeopathy. First of all, the beginners are having low confidence level, so if we handle them badly, it will make the situation worse. Have a great day doctor.
-
Permalink Reply by Vaikunthanath das Kaviraj. on
-
Since homoeopathy is a science, combinations are simply not scientific, because they fail to follow the rules of the science. That is what we have to tell the neonates. We have to encourage them to be scientific and not be like allopaths. If they have a low confidence level, then that can be boosted by pointing out the science and telling them they are scientists.
-
Permalink Reply by Dr Muhammed Rafeeque on
-
Yes, i fully agree with you - we have to encourage them to be a better Homoeopath.
-
Permalink Reply by Madhu Azad on -
THANK YOU ALL for providing me so much of practical information...
I am a beginner and a follower of Dr.Hahnemann and his teachings but when i look around myself i found only few His followers and more of mixopaths and always wonder is it necessary to do mixopathy to b a successful homeopath??
Bt now I have the answer, "NO" it is not and even true homeopaths exist and doing wonders. I have regained confidence in single remedy prescription and learned a lot from here. Thanks for your interest and so much of these contribution. I feel Blessed.
Regards
Madhu Azad
-
Permalink Reply by Manpreet S Bindra on -
Somewhere still in the Medicine, ETHICS and PRINCIPLES matter to majority of Physicians. For the things to which Master had to struggle so hard, we are again indulging ourselves into, no matter what results are we getting with patients but the main issue is that it kills our conscience of being a Homoeopath
-
Permalink Reply by Dr Deepak Sharma on -
Those who are unable to find out "Similimum" or have less confidence in the "Posology" will use the mixtures of medicines or the patents.
© 2013 Created by Debby Bruck.
