Creating Waves of Awareness
Which Rubric To See? Thinks She is Beautiful.
Replies to This Discussion
-
Permalink Reply by Vaikunthanath das Kaviraj. on -
Arindam,
you wrote:
"someones physical beauty is not at all related with her attitude and behavior."
I disagree. You should come and have a look in the west. It is ONLY about physical beauty and attitude and behaviour. The entire advertisement industry runs on this principle. -
-
Permalink Reply by DR. ARINDAM DUTTA on -
Yes Kavi, not only in west, the trend is all over the globe where money becomes the only parameter of the society. From good mornings to good nights these advertising giants are embracing us all around- from our toothpastes to mosquito repellents!! Kavi, sometimes a thought comes to my mind- slowly but steadily we are heading towards our self destruction with a billboard in our hand - “advancement”.
Influenced by advertisement is a forced affair, where they set a trend to see the world with their eyes. But in my post I wanted to mean the natural instinct- what we see around us with our own eyes. Probably you didn't notice I used bold letters to write physical beauty.
Thank you for your learned comments on my post and wishing them again & again in my future posts in HWC. Regards.......................ARINDAM -
-
Permalink Reply by Dr. Paul Muttathukunnel on -
without knowing the whole case it is difficult to prescribe a correct remedy .
anyway the rubric for your question is :-
MIND; DELUSIONS, imaginations; beautiful, wonderful; she is beautiful and wants to be (SI-240) (1) : stram.122
MIND; DELUSIONS, imaginations; great person, is (K26, SI-294, G21) (body; greatness) (distinguished - divine - noble - powerful - prince - queen) (Egotism) (Insanity; megalomania) (23)
can you say how many doses of Platina you have given to this girl ? -
-
Permalink Reply by Dr.M.Senthil on -
dr neena singla, since am practising ROH ,which only considers mental state of the patient,the possible rubrics for this version may be,
1.boaster or.haugthy ,then
2.delusions-beautiful-she is beautiful and wants to be [ STRAMONIUM IS single medicine for this]
[the most suitable one will be 2nd rubric]
[ but this thought should be in the patients mind, and not the mothers guessings,]also what she says other than this.we have to look over it, but u can try STRAM now, as atleast it can produce some change in her manner,have u tried this, also dont look whether any other "stram" symptoms are present, no need for it,this is her mental feeling which is enough .. try dr good luck. -
-
Permalink Reply by Vaikunthanath das Kaviraj. on
-
If you practise considers only the mental state you are in illusion. Hahnemann says that we prescribe on totality of symptoms only to arrive at the similimum.
-
-
Permalink Reply by Dr. Paul Muttathukunnel on
-
I completly agree with you. It was not attemption to say " Give Stramonium on this Rubric" .
I just give the rubric for the question.
you can go through my blog http://www.homeopathyworldcommunity.com/profiles/blogs/the-dangerou...
prescribing only on mental symptoms is a dangerous practice - the so called , revelutionise Homoeopathy, predictive homoeopathy, the sensational homeopathy and so on. -
-
Permalink Reply by Vaikunthanath das Kaviraj. on
-
system builders, all.
-
-
Permalink Reply by Dr.M.Senthil on
-
yes dr,thank u for ur admonition,sorry if i have misguided...but i had miraculous cure with this type....but i agree u sir
-
-
Permalink Reply by DR. ARINDAM DUTTA on
-
Dr Senthil,
You have written-
"...since am practising ROH ,which only considers mental state of the patient..."
-- Your roh may consider that but HOMOEOPATHY does not.
..............ARINDAM -
-
Permalink Reply by Dr.M.Senthil on
-
,thanks dr, ,but i had miraculous cure by considering mental symptoms alone,
there is a great debate about it, we cant do that in this site,...sorry if i have misguided...i will post some cases later, if u dont mind....thanks sir for ur kind advice -
-
Permalink Reply by Muhammad Asif on -
Dr Neena Singla
& respected other Doctor's
The statement below
"SHE IS THE MOST BEAUTIFUL GIRL IN THE WORLD"
its not normal attitude if someone consider own self something at extream pride or fright.its a beginning of unreal state of mind..
it is well defined statement which called this is Warning Sign of Mania... currently showing SAD social anxietic disorder..
Very Common Symptoms of Early-Onset Disorder
Separation anxiety
Rages & explosive temper tantrums (lasting up to several hours)
Marked irritability
Oppositional behavior
Frequent mood swings
Distractibility
Hyperactivity
Impulsivity
Restlessness/ fidgetiness
Silliness, goofiness, giddiness
Racing thoughts
Aggressive behavior
Grandiosity
Carbohydrate cravings
Risk-taking behaviors
Depressed mood
Lethargy
Low self-esteem
Difficulty getting up in the morning
Social anxiety
Oversensitivity to emotional or environmental triggers
it also need differential diagnosis for exact disease..
for proper constitutional prescription need more behavioral inquire..
i be write down short repertory for initialization..
Lechesis..... Talkative. anger, abusive attitude, Rapid or pressured speech,Bossiness,
Rus Tox...... Restless, Hyper active, frequent talk, anger
Opium ...... Fright,fear,low self esteam, sleeplessness
staphusgaria... anger++,abusive difficult to focus,less attention on study,Frequent mood swings,
Oppositional behavior
am sorry to all respected teachers am not opposing,its just my experience at same conditions..
and shearing with all of you.
after years that state of mind patients face episodes of manic depressive illness in there entire life when they opposed, criticized and discourage by others. They alway need emotional stability at there pinching end, if others didn't find there real need then they will become violent, destructive and sometime go in silence.
The best way to treat these patients, psychotherapy acombine with remedy. -
- ‹ Previous
- 1
- 2
- Next ›
© 2013 Created by Debby Bruck.
