New Publication
Homeopathy in Intensive Care
and Emergency Medicine
Homeopathy First Magazine
Best Vitamin C Drink 
Learn More With Caralyn 
Coupon SHOPWITHHWC

 

Homeopathy World Community

Creating Waves of Awareness

Boots hit by mass homeopathy 'overdose'-Comments

I have posted the following comments on the Telegraph.co.uk on the above news item.

(1) I have read the post in the Telegraph.co.uk and all the comments thereon.

There is a natural law' Nothing in this world exhausts, matter turns into energy and energy turns into matter'.

One agrees or not, but this law is there.

The question I would ask is as to what happened to the molecules of the drug substance which is used for the first dilution and subsequent dilutions Avogadro's number?

A second (time) can be divided into millionth or even higher fraction than why can't a molecule can be divided beyond Avogadro's number. Theoretically possible. Is'nt it. In 2009 scientists have successfully split electron into two (which was supposed to be impossible in 2008). May be succusion does the same to homeopathic dilution?

Another point. When one deals with human beings, who are different and unique, the idea of RCT is absurd. And why clinical benefit is ignored and something beyond understanding (as on date, not necessarily forever)is repeatedly commented upon. Blushing do occur to all of us once a while, but we do not know the exact underlying mechanism. There are many other phenomena, which we do not know much about today.

Many wise people talk about controls in comparing the results of a new drugs with proven drugs. I offer any one to undertake a controlled study of homeopathic medicine. Its simple and would consume little time. People over 50-60, especially women, develop osteoarthritic knees and lumbar spondylosis. They take dietary supplements rich in Calcium (mostly in Europe and US) and analgesic+ antiinflammatory drugs.Pain is relieved for 4-5 hours and they have to repeat the dose and go on taking drugs on the regular basis.We know the clinical analgesic effects of drugs in such cases.

I use a homeopathic regimen of two medicines(not named here for reasons of their abuse) administered individually in alternation. The relief from pain starts within 3-4 days and pain disappears in 7-10 days. After that some time drug holidays lasting for 15 days to a month would also be without pain.Both the medicines are homeopathic pharmacopoeal preparations.

It is a simple exercise and can be conducted anywhere lasting only 3-4 months. I am willing to be part of the exercise.I can send both medicines with code Nos. to eliminate subjective bias.

Instruments developed for assessment of pain in OA as are universally adopted may be used to assess the progress.

And remember I haven't talked about Bone density. I have talked about pain only.

Vijay

V.P.Singh M.D.(Homeopathy)
on January 22, 2010
at 06:47 AM
Report this comment


(2) Well said Oliver. Hope others would realise their folly.In medicine clinical evidence is equally important. And as I said earlier, I damn care about statistics, if I cure only one case of disease said to be incurable. What can be true for one can be true for others as well.

Apparently anti-homeropathy have considerations other than their love for science,which in any case based and developed on theories. Homeopathy is also based on theories which have stood test of the time.

Exercise such as one under reference here would only benefit Homeopathy. Its not possible to kill truth.
V.P.Singh M.D. (Homoeopathy)
on January 22, 2010
at 10:27 AM
Report this comment

(3) In my comment to the post made on Jan.22 I had written "many wise people talk about controls in comparing the results of a new drug with proven drugs in a particular disease condition. I offer any one to undertake a controlled study of homeopathic medicine. Its simple and would consume little time. People over 50-60, especially women, develop osteoarthritic knees and lumbar spondylosis. They take dietary supplements rich in Calcium (mostly in Europe and US) and analgesic+ anti-inflammatory drugs.Pain is relieved for 4-5 hours and they have to repeat the dose and go on taking drugs on the regular basis.We know the clinical analgesic effects of drugs in such cases.

I use a homeopathic regimen of two medicines(not named here for reasons of their abuse) administered individually in alternation. The relief from pain starts within 3-4 days and pain disappears in 7-10 days. After that some time drug holidays lasting for 15 days to a month would also be without pain.Both the medicines are homeopathic pharmacopoeal preparations.

It is a simple exercise and can be conducted anywhere lasting only 3-4 months. I am willing to be part of the exercise.I can send both medicines with code nos. to eliminate subjective bias.

I had made the offer. Now I implore or and if need be challenge any one to undertake the study.

True we do not know as yet as to what is there in the homoeopathic dilution which is therapeutically active, but clinical observations we have made over the years, say 200+ plus years, are of immense valuen to us. After all you vcan't fool patients all the time. Even an illetrate patient understands fully well as to whether he is benefitted or not.

We have not seen GOD or a soul, yet we see the manifestations everyday.

In times of adversity, even a physical scientist, who believes only Physics and Chemistry, utters 'My GOD'. You masy call it conditioning of the mind for generations or cultural tradition, but they too seek help from someone up there whom they have not seen.

And they go to church every Sunday (most of them if not all), again you may call it a ritual.

In the end I would seek an end to this verbal duel in the name of Science which most of us do not understand fully well.

RESPECT HUMAN RIGHTS. If they are not well known than read HIV/AIDS biography. I do my own things, you do yours. Where is the conflict unless I trip on your toe.

My challenge about relief in pains of Osteoarthritis stands.
Any TAKERS.

Views: 84

Comment by Debby Bruck on January 23, 2010 at 10:47am
Thank you. E=MC2

Comment

You need to be a member of Homeopathy World Community to add comments!

Join Homeopathy World Community

Search This Site

GET ➤ 
Cancer and Homeopathy
Best Vitamin C Drink
Enter SHOPWITHHWC
for $3 coupon

AGRO HOMEOPATHY

RADIO & VIDEO SHOWS

© 2017   Created by Debby Bruck.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service

Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...